Part of Clarence Darrow’s defence speech in the closing arguments of
Henry Sweet’s trial on 11th of May 1926 in the recorders court, Detroit, Michigan
Now, gentlemen, I say you are prejudiced. I fancy everyone of you are,
otherwise you would have some companions amongst these colored people. You will
overcome it, I believe, in the trial of this case. But they tell me there is no
race prejudice, and it is plain nonsense, and nothing else.
Who are we, anyway?
A child is born into this world without any knowledge of any sort. He has a
brain which is a piece of putty; he inherits nothing in the way of knowledge or
of ideas. If he is white, he knows nothing about color. He has no antipathy to
the black.
The black and the white both
will live together and play together, but as soon as the baby is born we begin
giving him ideas. We begin planting seeds in his mind. We begin telling him he
must do this and he must not do that. We tell him about race and social
equality and the thousands of things that men talk about until he grows up. It
has been trained into us, and you, gentlemen, bring that feeling into this jury
box, and that feeling which is a part of your life long training.
You need not tell me you are not prejudiced. I know better. We are not very
much but a bundle of prejudices anyhow. We are prejudiced against other
peoples’ color. Prejudiced against other men’s religion; prejudiced against
other peoples’ politics. Prejudiced against peoples’ looks. Prejudiced about
the way they dress. We are full of prejudices. You can teach a man anything
beginning with the child; you can make anything out of him, and we are not
responsible for it. Here and there some of us haven’t any prejudices on some
questions, but if you look deep enough you will find them; and we all know it.
All I hope for, gentlemen of the jury, is this: That you are strong enough, and
honest enough, and decent enough to lay it aside in this case and decide it as
you ought to. And I say, there is no man in Detroit that doesn’t know
that these defendants, everyone of them, did right. There isn't a man in
Detroit who doesn’t know that the defendant did his duty, and that this case is
an attempt to send him and his companions to prison because they defended their
constitutional rights. It is a wicked attempt, and you are asked to be a party
to it. You know it. I don’t need to talk to this jury about the facts in this
case. There is no man who can read or can understand that does not know the
facts. Is there prejudice in it?
Now,
let’s see. I don’t want to lean very much on your intelligence. I don’t need
much. I just need a little. Would this case be in this court if these
defendants were not black? Would we be standing in front of you if these
defendants were not black? Would anybody be asking you to send a boy to prison
for life for defending his brother’s home and protecting his own life, if his
face wasn’t black? What were the people in the neighborhood of Charlevoix and
Garland Streets doing on that fatal night? There isn’t a child that doesn't
know. Have you any doubt as to why they were there?
Clarence Darrow
No comments:
Post a Comment